Walking into the physical QZAP archive as an intern and a long-time zine dork is overwhelming. Thereâs so much stuff. There are a lot of things I have read, or that are made by people I know, and seeing those items in the folders feels like running into a friend. There is also a lot of work in the archives by people I donât know firsthand, but who are some of the people I look up to most, and regard as vital elders and ancestors. The first thing I saw in the archives that made me feel completely teary and overwhelmed was gendertrash (also known as Gender Trash or gendertrash from hell).
As someone who spends a lot of time in both Montreal and Toronto, I regard gendertrash and its authors as a vital part of the trans cultures of both of those cities. Published under the label of genderpress, which also sold some truly excellent buttons, gendertrash was produced primarily by Xanthra Phillippa, who was a fixture of Torontoâs trans communities until her death in 2014, and âJeanne B,â aka the filmmaker and activist Mirha-Soleil Ross, who was originally from Montreal.
(A note on names: I donât usually use my full or legal name in my zines, and I deeply respect peopleâs right to remain anonymous or pseudonymous in their zines. Since Ross is widely acknowledged online as one of the zineâs authors, Iâm erring here on the side of giving her credit for her work, rather than sticking with her pseudonym.)
There were four issues of gendertrash. The first issue, which is the one held in QZAPâs archives, was published in Toronto in the spring of 1993, 31 years ago. The other issues are also available online through the Arquives, which also, delightfully, holds many of the original paste-ups for the zines.
âÎâÎâÎ
Like many zines, especially of its era, gendertrash contains a wide range of content and tone. (As someone who makes zines that tend to be more like a cohesive essay or book, I think itâs doing me a lot of good to look at this style of zine, and it makes me want to make something thatâs a mishmash of personal anecdotes, opinions, resources, recipes, creative writing, etc. â that part of the messiness and imperfection of zines got away from me at some point.)
gendertrash places sex work and sex workers squarely at the centre of its focus, where it belongs. To talk about transness without talking about sex work would be to leave out a huge swath of the community, and many of its strongest pillars, including Ross, whose sex work and creative work have been closely intertwined.
Some parts of the zine are squarely pragmatic. It reproduces a brochure of safety guidelines for electrolysis practitioners, so that electrolysis clients can know what standards to hold their practitioners to. It has a section at the end of local resources for sex workers, people seeking healthcare, and for those experiencing sexual violence, noting which organizations âhave no problems with TS’sâ or are âaware of the problems of TS youth (esp with shelters & housing)â. It also notes local events like the queer zine gathering Spew 3 at the queer theatre Buddies In Bad Times, which is blessedly still with us.
âÎâÎâÎ
The zine also contains installments of TSe TSe TerroriSm, a serialized novel about âsome members of Toronto’s gender described community,â by Phillips. When its protagonist is street-harassed by some men in a Jeep, she sets off,
âTwo huge Catherine Wheels, one pink, one blue, as big as suns, rise up out of the fireball, lighting the street, buildings, stores & all the people rushing out onto balconies & pouring out of the restaurants & nearby shops to stare, laugh, applaud, cheer & give deliberately misleading or useless information to the cops, now beginning to arrive in a parade of sirens & lights, to investigate the blackened & smoking carcass that once was a Jeep.â
After escaping, sheâs comforted by a friend or lover, sharing her rage and sorrow that passers-by were,
âcelebrating like it’s something wonderful & exciting & like i-did-it-all-for-them, instead of the nightmare it really was. it’s not a game or a party. i mean, where the fuck were they, when i was being attacked? hiding inside their safe closets, shaking & shivering, but as soon as they see & hear the fireworks, out they come with fucking bells on. those creeps nearly killed, would have killed me for certain – it was that dangerous & here they are, out celebrating. i kill four creeps by setting them on fire because it was necessary. i’d do it again if necessary, but it’s nothing to cheer aboutâ
In its combination of magic realism with a clear-eyed look at the emotional and physical toll of transmisogny, it reminded me of the work of another Toronto-based writer: Kai Cheng Thomâs beautiful book Fierce Femmes and Notorious Liars.
âÎâÎâÎ
The first issue of gendertrash also includes a fascinating glossary of âTS Words & Phrases.â As my piece last week on the QZAP blog shows, I am deeply fascinated with the numerous ways that gender and sexual minority folks have described ourselves over the years, and our consistent vehemence that the current terms are the only correct ones.
gendertrashâs glossary, also reflected throughout the zine, uses the term âmembers of the gender communities,â instead of what they call âthe clumsy-sounding transpersons.â The people I would refer to as cis, it defines as âgenetics, genetically/chromosonally described/determinedâ. This distinction is also delightfully made in the zineâs usage instructions, which state that,
âmaterial in gendertrash may be copied for personal use by any gender described person or for publication within any non-profit journal for gender described, as long as the proper credit is given. Material may be copied & used by genetics only upon prior written consent from genderpress.â
One of the most interesting glossary entries to me is their use of the term âgender orientedâ, which is used to refer to âwimmin, men or people who attracted to TS’sâ, whether those people are genetics or in the gender communities, or what Iâd call trans or cis. Extending the umbrella out over people who date and/or fuck trans people isnât usually part of the conversation in the circles Iâve travelled in, and I find it interesting to think about! This concept also comes out in the zineâs piece about the 1992 movie The Crying Game, which trans people in my life have felt a lot of ways about:
âThis man is spontaneously and strongly attracted to Dil for her female or non-male attributes. not her cock and balls. In fact, the main character thinks she is a genetic womyn & is surprised & upset to find out that she is not. Gay men will have to realize & accept the fact that genetic men who are attracted to us (TV, TG or TS) are not gay, but gender-oriented & that their numbers are constantly growing. In other words. we’re having a party & genetic gay men are not invited.â
(The glossary also includes the delightfully punk âin the pitâ as a replacement for âin the closetâ, and the poignant entry âthatâs the way it is is the phrase we use to describe how we survive in this society.â)
There is so much for a contemporary trans reader to enjoy and learn from in gendertrash. Itâs a joy and a blessing to me that itâs been archived so that I can enjoy it 30+ years after it was published.
Lee P, interning at QZAP in summer 2024, is a long-time zine maker whose current project is Sheer Spite Press, a small press and zine distro. Originally from unceded Algonquin land, Lee calls TiohtiĂ :ke // Mooniyang // Montreal home. Lee is also a member of the organizing collective for Dickâs Lending Library, a community-run, local library of books by trans, non-binary, and Two-Spirit authors.